| 1st place | Rover's Day Out by Jack Welch |
| 2nd place | Broken Legs by Katherine Morayati |
| 3rd place | Snowquest by Eric Eve |
| 4th place | The Duel That Spanned the Ages by Oliver Ullmann |
| 5th place | Earl Grey by Rob Dubbin and Adam Parrish |
| 6th place | The Duel in the Snow by Utkonos |
| 7th place | Resonance by Matt Scarpino |
| 8th place | Interface by Ben Vegiard |
| 9th place | Byzantine Perspective by Lea Albaugh (writing as “Lea”) |
| 10th place | Grounded in Space by Matt Wigdahl |
| 11th place | Yon Astounding Castle! of some sort by Duncan Bowsman (writing as “Tiberius Thingamus”) |
| 12th place | Condemned by Mark Jones (writing as “a Delusioned Teenager”) |
| 13th place | Eruption by Richard Bos |
| 14th place | Beta Tester by Darren Ingram |
| 15th place | The Ascot by Duncan Bowsman |
| 16th place | Spelunker's Quest by Tom Murrin |
| 17th place | The Believable Adventures of an Invisible Man by Hannes Schueller |
| 18th place | The Grand Quest by Owen Parish |
| 19th place | Star Hunter by Chris K. |
| 20th place | GATOR-ON, Friend to Wetlands! by Dave Horlick |
| 21st place | Gleaming the Verb by Kevin Jackson-Mead |
| 22nd place | zork, buried chaos by Brad Renshaw (writing as “bloodbath”) |
| 23rd place | Trap Cave by Comazombie |
| 24th place | The Hangover by Will Conine (writing as “Red conine”) |
The organizer of the 2009 Annual Interactive Fiction Competition was Stephen Granade.